Form 5471 Penalties: $60,000 Risk and Relief Options

Understanding the penalty structure, relief options, and how to protect yourself from severe IRS consequences for foreign corporation reporting failures

Quick Facts:

$10,000 Initial penalty per form
$60,000 Maximum penalty per form
90 days IRS notice response period
10% Foreign tax credit reduction

The Stakes: Why Form 5471 Penalties Are Serious

Form 5471 penalties are among the highest in the entire tax code. The $10,000 initial penalty can grow to $60,000 per form—and these penalties apply per foreign corporation, per year.

If you own interests in multiple foreign corporations or have missed multiple years, your exposure can become devastating. For a complete overview of Form 5471 requirements, see our Complete Guide to Form 5471.

Note on OBBBA Changes (2026+): While the One Big Beautiful Bill Act significantly changed CFC taxation rules (GILTI becomes NCTI, QBAI eliminated, new pro rata share rules), Form 5471 penalty amounts remain unchanged at $10,000–$60,000 per form. The increased complexity of the new rules makes professional compliance assistance even more valuable.

The Cost of Non-Compliance

Consider this scenario: A taxpayer owns 3 foreign corporations and has missed filing for 2 years.

Potential penalty exposure: 3 corporations × 2 years × $60,000 = $360,000

Plus: Criminal penalty risk and extended statute of limitations on related tax assessments.

Understanding the Penalty Structure

Section 6038(b) Penalties: Failure to File

Initial Penalty:

$10,000 per foreign corporation per annual accounting period
Applies to failure to furnish information required by Section 6038(a)
Assessed automatically by the IRS upon detection

Continuation Penalties:

If information is not filed within 90 days after IRS notice
Additional $10,000 for each 30-day period (or fraction thereof)
Continues until information is provided
Maximum additional penalty: $50,000

Total Maximum: $60,000 per form ($10,000 initial + $50,000 continuation)

Section 6046 Penalties: Reporting Failures

$10,000 penalty per reportable transaction
Additional penalties for continued failure
Applies to reporting of organization, reorganization, and acquisition events

Foreign Tax Credit Reduction

Beyond monetary penalties, non-compliance affects your foreign tax credits:

10% reduction in foreign tax credits under Sections 901 and 960
Additional 5% reduction for each 3-month period of continued failure
Can result in complete loss of foreign tax credits

Penalty Accumulation Timeline

Time After IRS Notice	Penalty Increment	Cumulative Penalty
Initial failure	$10,000	$10,000
91+ days	+$10,000	$20,000
121+ days	+$10,000	$30,000
151+ days	+$10,000	$40,000
181+ days	+$10,000	$50,000
211+ days	+$10,000	$60,000 (maximum)

Criminal Penalties

In egregious cases, failure to file Form 5471 can lead to criminal prosecution.

IRC Section 7203: Failure to File

Classification: Misdemeanor
Fine: Up to $25,000 for individuals ($100,000 for corporations)
Imprisonment: Up to 1 year

IRC Section 7206: Fraud and False Statements

Classification: Felony
Fine: Up to $100,000 for individuals ($500,000 for corporations)
Imprisonment: Up to 3 years

IRC Section 7207: Fraudulent Returns

Classification: Misdemeanor
Fine: Up to $10,000 for individuals ($50,000 for corporations)
Imprisonment: Up to 1 year

When Criminal Penalties May Apply:

Willful failure to file

Fraudulent statements on returns

Pattern of non-compliance over multiple years

Clear intent to evade taxes

If you have any concern about willfulness, seek professional help immediately before taking action.

The Farhy Decision: Recent Legal Development

What Happened

In Farhy v. Commissioner (decided in 2023 and affirmed in 2024), the Tax Court ruled that the IRS lacks statutory authority to administratively assess Form 5471 penalties. Instead, the IRS must pursue a civil lawsuit in federal court to collect these penalties.

What This Means

The penalty itself still exists ($10,000–$60,000)
The filing requirement is unchanged
The collection mechanism has changed
The IRS must now file a lawsuit instead of automatic assessment

What This Does NOT Mean

Does NOT eliminate penalties
Does NOT eliminate your filing requirement
Does NOT mean you should ignore compliance
Does NOT protect against criminal penalties

Practical Impact

The IRS may be more selective in pursuing penalties
Reasonable cause defenses remain critically important
Compliance is still strongly recommended
This may affect IRS enforcement priorities going forward

Reasonable Cause Defense

The reasonable cause defense is your primary protection against Form 5471 penalties.

IRS Standards

To establish reasonable cause, you must demonstrate that:

You exercised ordinary business care and prudence
You were unable to comply despite reasonable efforts
Your situation warrants relief based on facts and circumstances

Factors the IRS Considers

Knowledge and Experience: Your level of tax sophistication
Reliance on Professional: Whether you sought advice from a qualified tax advisor
Disclosure to Advisor: Whether you fully disclosed your foreign interests
Prior Compliance: Your history of timely and accurate filing
Circumstances: Events beyond your control that prevented compliance

What Generally Works

Full disclosure of all foreign interests to a qualified tax professional
Professional advised (incorrectly) that no filing was required
Documented reasonable efforts to comply
Prompt filing once the obligation was discovered
First-time violation with an otherwise clean compliance history

What Generally Does Not Work

“I didn’t know about the requirement” standing alone
Failure to disclose foreign interests to your tax advisor
Ignoring professional advice to file
Pattern of non-compliance across multiple years
Any indication of tax evasion motive

Case Study: Flume v. Commissioner

In this case, the taxpayer failed to disclose foreign corporations to their tax preparer. Because the preparer was never informed, they couldn’t advise on Form 5471 requirements. The court rejected the taxpayer’s reasonable cause defense.

Lesson: Full disclosure to your tax advisor is critical for establishing reasonable cause.

Penalty Relief Programs

Several IRS programs offer potential relief from Form 5471 penalties.

1. Delinquent International Information Return Submission Procedures (DIIRSP)

Eligibility:

Not currently under IRS civil examination
Not under IRS criminal investigation
Not previously contacted by the IRS about these returns

Requirements:

File all delinquent returns with required schedules
Attach a reasonable cause statement
Certify that no related entity engaged in tax evasion
Sign under penalties of perjury

Process:

File with your income tax return, OR
File separately if no other return is due
Use the appropriate IRS filing address
Include a detailed reasonable cause explanation

2. Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures

For Non-Willful Taxpayers:

File 3 years of delinquent income tax returns
File 6 years of delinquent FBARs (if applicable)
Submit Form 14653 (domestic) or 14654 (foreign) certifying non-willfulness
Pay any tax and interest due

Domestic vs. Foreign Streamlined:

Domestic (living in U.S.): 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty on highest account balance
Foreign (living abroad): No miscellaneous penalty

3. First Time Abatement (FTA)

Limited Applicability:

Generally tied to the underlying return’s abatement eligibility
Requires a clean compliance history
Not specifically designed for international information returns
May apply if your Form 1120 or Form 1065 qualifies

4. Requesting Abatement After Assessment

If penalties have already been assessed:

File Form 843 (Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement)
Attach a comprehensive reasonable cause statement
Provide all relevant facts and circumstances
Request abatement of the assessed penalty

How to Write a Reasonable Cause Statement

A strong reasonable cause statement can mean the difference between full penalty assessment and complete abatement.

Required Elements

Identification: Your name, taxpayer identification number, and tax years involved
Facts: Complete description of your circumstances
Ordinary Business Care: How you attempted to comply with your obligations
Cause of Failure: Why compliance did not occur
Corrective Action: Steps you have taken to fix the problem
Non-Willfulness: Statement that the failure was not willful
No Tax Evasion: Certification that no evasion occurred

Sample Structure

Statement of Reasonable Cause for Form 5471 Penalty Abatement

Taxpayer: [Full Name, SSN/TIN]

Tax Years: [List years]

Form: 5471 – Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations

Facts: I am a U.S. citizen who owns [percentage] of [Foreign Corporation Name], incorporated in [Country]. I was unaware of the Form 5471 filing requirement until [date or event that triggered awareness].

Ordinary Business Care: I engaged [CPA/Tax Professional Name] to prepare my annual tax returns. I disclosed all domestic income sources and believed my tax obligations were being properly addressed.

Cause of Failure: My failure to file Form 5471 was due to [honest misunderstanding of the requirements / incorrect professional advice / complexity of international tax rules]. I had no intent to evade taxes or conceal my foreign corporate interests from the IRS.

Corrective Action: Upon discovering this filing obligation, I immediately [engaged an international tax specialist / prepared all delinquent forms / filed corrected returns with this submission].

Certification: I certify that [Foreign Corporation Name] was not engaged in any tax evasion scheme and that my failure to file Form 5471 was not willful.

Under penalties of perjury, I declare that the statements in this document are true, correct, and complete to the best of my knowledge and belief.

[Signature] [Date]

Statute of Limitations Impact

Form 5471 non-compliance has serious implications for the statute of limitations.

General Rules

Normal statute of limitations: 3 years from filing
Extended for substantial understatement: 6 years

Form 5471 Impact

Failure to file Form 5471 can keep the statute of limitations open indefinitely
The IRS can assess taxes related to CFC income at any time
This remains true until a compliant Form 5471 is filed

Important Implication: Filing delinquent forms starts the statute of limitations clock running, which may actually benefit you in the long run by providing finality.

Prevention Strategies

Annual Compliance Checklist

Review all foreign entity ownership annually
Determine filing category for each foreign entity
Calculate required schedules based on your category
Prepare Form 5471 with your tax return
File by deadline (including extensions)
Maintain documentation for at least 7 years

Work with Qualified Professionals

Engage a CPA with specific international tax expertise
Fully disclose all foreign interests—every entity, every year
Document advice received in writing
Keep records of professional communications

Changes to Monitor

Acquisition or disposition of foreign stock
Changes in CFC status
Changes in control or ownership percentages
New U.S. shareholders of existing CFCs
Immigration status changes

What to Do If You Haven’t Filed

Step 1: Don’t Panic

Penalties are serious, but relief is available. Acting promptly significantly improves your outcomes.

Step 2: Assess Your Situation

How many years are delinquent?
Are you currently under IRS examination?
Is there any tax evasion concern?
What is your overall compliance history?
What is your filer category for each foreign corporation?

Step 3: Choose the Right Path

DIIRSP: Best for most situations with reasonable cause
Streamlined: For broader non-compliance issues (FBARs, income tax returns)
Voluntary Disclosure: For situations involving willfulness concerns
Professional guidance is essential for choosing correctly

Step 4: Prepare and File

Gather all required information about the foreign corporations
Prepare delinquent forms accurately and completely
Write a strong reasonable cause statement
File through the appropriate procedure

Step 5: Maintain Future Compliance

Set up systems for ongoing compliance
Calendar all filing deadlines
Engage a professional for annual preparation
Understand GILTI and Subpart F reporting requirements for CFCs

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the penalty for not filing Form 5471?

The initial penalty is $10,000 per foreign corporation per year. If you fail to file within 90 days of an IRS notice, additional penalties of $10,000 per 30-day period apply, up to a maximum of $60,000 per form.

Can Form 5471 penalties be waived?

Yes. The IRS can abate penalties if you demonstrate reasonable cause for the failure. Relief programs like DIIRSP and Streamlined Filing also offer penalty-free or reduced-penalty filing options for eligible taxpayers.

What is reasonable cause for Form 5471?

Reasonable cause means you exercised ordinary business care and prudence but were still unable to comply. This often involves reliance on professional tax advice, honest misunderstanding of complex rules, or circumstances beyond your control.

How do I file delinquent Form 5471?

Use the Delinquent International Information Return Submission Procedures (DIIRSP) if you are not under examination. File the delinquent forms with a reasonable cause statement either with your current tax return or separately.

Does the Farhy decision eliminate penalties?

No. The Farhy decision changed how the IRS collects penalties (through civil lawsuit rather than automatic assessment) but did not eliminate the penalties themselves. The filing requirement remains in full effect.

Will I go to jail for not filing Form 5471?

Criminal penalties are possible in cases of willful failure to file or fraud, but they are rare. Most non-compliance is handled through civil penalties. However, if willfulness is a concern, you should seek professional guidance immediately.

How far back do I need to file?

Under DIIRSP, you typically file all delinquent years. Under Streamlined Filing, you file 3 years of income tax returns and 6 years of FBARs. Consult a professional to determine the right approach for your situation.

Can I file delinquent forms without penalty?

Possibly. DIIRSP allows penalty-free filing if you have reasonable cause. Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures (for those living abroad) may also result in no penalty. Each case depends on the specific facts.

What if I can’t pay the penalty?

If penalties are assessed and you cannot pay, you can request an installment agreement or explore offer-in-compromise options. However, pursuing penalty abatement through reasonable cause is typically the better first step.

Should I use an attorney or CPA?

For most Form 5471 penalty situations, a CPA with international tax expertise is appropriate. If criminal exposure is a concern or you anticipate IRS litigation, adding a tax attorney may be advisable.

Professional Penalty Relief Services

SDO CPA provides comprehensive Form 5471 penalty relief services:

Penalty exposure assessment
Reasonable cause statement preparation
DIIRSP and Streamlined filings
Delinquent Form 5471 preparation
IRS correspondence and appeals
Ongoing compliance monitoring

Form 5471 penalties can be significant. Professional guidance may help. Connect with SDO CPA for a confidential consultation to assess your situation and determine the best path forward.

This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. Penalty situations are fact-specific and require professional evaluation. Consult a qualified tax professional before taking action on Form 5471 compliance issues.

Table of Contents